What is the churn lifecycle?
The subscriber journey is not linear. It's a cycle of discovery, purchase, potential cancellation, and — for savvy businesses — resubscribing. Understanding the specific drivers of churn is essential for mitigating it. Cancellation is rarely a random act; it is overwhelmingly driven by economic considerations, outdated payments, and a perceived decline in the service's core value.
of consumers who are likely to cancel a service point to high costs as a reason, making it the single biggest driver of anticipated churn
When subscribers who anticipate canceling in the next year were asked for their reasoning, the answers were starkly financial. High costs (41%) and price hikes (30%) were the primary drivers cited by a wide margin. Price sensitivity is a constant and powerful factor in the subscriber lifecycle. Beyond the general price, specific events can act as powerful churn triggers that vary by industry. A drop in quality not only drives up perceived costs but also puts the value of a service under intense scrutiny.
While the primary drivers of churn are universal, the propensity to cancel can vary by region. The data indicates that U.S. subscribers are more likely to have cancelled subscriptions in the past 12 months than their European counterparts in most verticals. For instance, U.S. consumers reported higher cancellation rates for streaming video services (29% vs. 22% in Europe), gaming (18% vs. 12%), and pet products (13% vs. 9%).
When a service falls short in delivering value, the likelihood of subscribers canceling their subscription increases. Subscribers were asked, “If the following scenario were to happen, how likely would you be to cancel your current subscription?” And the answers back up the value statements you’ll find throughout the report.
Likelihood of cancelling by scenario and subscription type
U.S. subscribers report a higher likelihood to cancel across nearly every negative scenario compared to their European counterparts. This is especially true for a lack of personalization. For example, in the Beauty category, 59% of U.S. subscribers would be likely to cancel due to a lack of personalization, compared to only 42% in Europe. Similar large gaps exist for Health & Fitness (64% U.S. vs. 25% Europe) and Travel (58% U.S. vs. 49% Europe), suggesting U.S. consumers place a much higher premium on personalized experiences and are more willing to churn without them.
“Personalization makes things easier for the customer, but on the business side, it requires the right technology to manage effectively.”
— Andrei Rebrov, Co-Founder & Former CTO, Scentbird
Understanding why subscribers churn is only half the battle. The other half is understanding how your churn rate and pricing strategies compare to the rest of the industry. Tools like Recurly Compass can allow you to benchmark your performance, discover playbooks to combat churn, and put your growth on autopilot.
It's not all bad news when it comes to churn. Among the 1,000 participants surveyed, 43% reported not canceling a single subscription in the past year. When subscribers perceive value in a service, they are likely to remain loyal for extended periods.
How likely are you to keep your subscription service?
When does churn usually happen?
The subscription market is dynamic, with high rates of both adoption and churn. In the past 12 months, 80% of consumers purchased a streaming video subscription, making it the most popular category. However, it also saw the highest number of cancellations, at 26%. Higher rates of acquisition usually mean higher rates of churn as well. However, an undeniable factor of churn is when it takes place.
Across all verticals, an average of 66% of cancellations occurred within the first 12 months. The food subscription category faces the most acute early churn, with 45% of cancellations happening in under six months. The most significant statistical churn happens within the first year across all verticals.
Duration subscribed before cancellation
The subscription box challenge:
For food subscriptions, a staggering 45% of all cancellations occur in the first six months. These businesses must prove immense value and foster habit-formation starting from the very first delivery.
The first few months are critical, and a generic welcome email won’t cut it. To reduce early churn, companies must make a big impact quickly. For example, a subscriber joining for novelty could get a welcome series highlighting new and exclusive products, while one joining for cost savings might see a flow showing their savings after their first order. Tailoring these onboarding flows to the subscriber's motivation prove the service's value from day one, boosting the chances of building long-term loyalty. Tools like Recurly Engage can help you achieve this and more in-app across your subscriptions.
Switching services
The primary reasons subscribers switch providers are to get better pricing (42%) and to gain access to exclusive content/products (41%). They are actively seeking a better deal or a superior offering. When these same switchers were asked what their previous provider could have done to prevent them from leaving, the answers were direct, strikingly uniform, and overwhelmingly focused on price.
Reason for switching providers (overall)
Better pricing
Exclusive content/products
Superior quality
Positive reviews*
Flexible subscription options
Poor customer support
What would have prevented (overall)
Offered a lower price
Improve content/product
Offered a discount
Better flexibility in payments
Offered more attractive bundle*
Be more proactive with issues
Engage with me more often
Engage with me less often
Provide a referral code
of consumers who switched providers said their previous service could have kept them simply by offering a lower price, and another 34% said the same of offering a discount. This shows that two-thirds of the top three win-back tactics are purely price-based incentives.
Churned customers are not looking for apologies or complex gestures. They are looking for a better deal. The fact that a simple discount is just as powerful as a fundamental price drop or product improvement shows how receptive these customers are to straightforward, value-based incentives. They are not necessarily gone for good; they are waiting for a compelling reason to return.
Subscription companies must be extremely cautious about price increases, as they are the most reliable catalyst for customer loss. Furthermore, any changes that degrade the core service, remove popular features, or introduce technical friction must be carefully managed. Win-back strategies should be direct, proactive, and built around clear value propositions. Instead of waiting for churned customers to forget their grievances, brands should target them with the very things that would have kept them in the first place. Proactively offer competitive pricing, targeted discounts to at-risk or recently churned cohorts, and messaging around new content or product improvements.
sales@recurly.com
+1.844.732.8759
recurly.com
©2025 Recurly, Inc. All rights reserved